Access Code: 132-263-437
Please join my meeting from your computer, tablet or smartphone.
https://www.gotomeet.me/
Business Roundtable—Purpose of a Corporation
Pre- August 2019 Maximize Shareholder Value
Corporate Responsibility per Milton Friedman
1970 essay- Maximize Returns to Shareholder
Friedman’s thesis: Corporations are not to make contributions for
“social causes”, shareholders can choose what to give.
Further- Corporations are to obey all laws and regulations.
If corporations make “contributions”, the directors must
conclude such donations create good will and enhance sales.
Current example: Orvis gives 5% of pretax profits for “environmental
causes”. (Could they give 15%?
Comments from Harvard Law School Forum
Re: Business Roundtable Statement on Corporate Mission
Corporate Directors have a fiduciary duty to act in shareholder interest
Thus, decisions not in shareholder interest are illegal
Actions taken by directors will be presumed to be in shareholder interest or they would not be taken.
Directors must adhere to the law so that new Legislative mandates may promote or presume to benefit other stakeholders, but at a cost to shareholders.
Overall question: To what extent do we desire the government to impose
rules that will decrease business profits in order to strive for other benefits
What does the Business Roundtable expect or hope to change with revised statement of purpose?
Former “purpose”: “Maximize shareholder Value”
New “purpose”: “Act to benefit all stakeholders”
Stakeholders: customers, employees, suppliers, communities, and shareholders
Possible intentions:
Change corporate reporting on selective topics?
Motivate investments into areas not directly in shareholder interest?
Motivate shareholder resolutions on new corporate action
Bring about new government rules on business actions
Potential areas of Government mandates: ESG
(Environment, Social, Government)
Action regarding global warming;
Other environment improvement measures
Reduction of income inequality
Increase diversity in management personnel
Impose unnecessary costs for named investments
Establish more “days off” for employees
From the WSJ. Financial Advisers Turn to ESG, Warily – WSJ
IEA warns oil companies doing nothing on emissions is not an option
https://eresearch.fidelity.com/eresearch/goto/evaluate/news/basicNewsStory.jhtml?symbols=XOM&storyid=202001191929RTRSNEWSCOMBINED_KBN1ZJ005-OUSBS_1
Capitalism, Alone’ Review: Inclined Toward Inequality
Capitalism Alone
https://lucidmanager.org/milton-friedman-corporate-social-responsibility/
https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2019/09/26/analysis-of-the-business-roundtable-statement/
https://www.coursehero.com/file/8478280/Purpose-of-the-Corporation/
The Davos Crowd Embraces Big Global Government – WSJ